Works in Progress- Or, I Guess I'm Not Perfect After All...


I've also been working on a soy-free turkey-like recipe that can be made in advance in muffin tins and reheated. This would be great for singles or couples or people who are travelling on the holidays to eat with non-veg families. The method worked perfectly, but the mixture of spices and the ratio of "turkey" to filling needs to be adjusted.

I will, of course, post the recipes when I've perfected them in the off chance anyone cares. I just wanted you all to know that I haven't just been sitting around picking my nose. I have actually been in the kitchen cooking, albeit unsuccessfully.
And hey, while we're on the subject of recipe testing, I have a question perhaps some of you can answer. I personally test my own recipes on friends and family, simply because I want them to reflect my personal tastes. I do ask for feedback when I serve up something new, because if everyone at the table doesn't love it, then generally this means it needs more work. I also don't volunteer to test other people's recipes, because I am very fussy girl with specific likes and dislikes, and the odds of me liking someone elses recipes precisely as written are slim, quite frankly. I fuck with every recipe I look at, so my feedback would not be valuable.
However, I have never read a post about recipe testing where the blogger did not just lovelovelove the recipe he/she just tested so much that he/she wants to marry it and carry it off to bed with them. How can this be possible? Does every food tester simply adore every recipe they test? Can any cookbook developer be so wonderful that their creations seem to appeal to the entire planet? This makes me suspicious, being the cranky old bitch that I am. I would be more inclined to go on to buy a cookbook if I had evidence that the wrinkles were being ironed out by the recipe testers, rather than being made to believe that every recipe springs forth from the writers brain perfect in every way. Now, I know that this must happen....those testers must be sharing their less-than-glowing feedback with the writer, otherwise, what is the point of testing? Now, how's about letting us all in on the process, since you're going to the trouble to post pictures of what you are testing? I'd find it refreshing to just once read a post that said something like this:
"I tested these TVP meatballs for Tracy at A Veg*n for Dinner. "

"I'm sorry Tracy, but these sucked big time. Oh sure, they looked lovely, and they stayed together well. But the consistency was something akin to those little rubber balls you get from a vending machine for ten cents, and the smell as they were cooking made me think of the sheep enclosure at my Grandma's farm. When I bit into one, it brought me back to the time when I found a lump on my dog's backside. Same consistency. Sorry, Tracy...good concept, but I think you need to get your ass into the kitchen and try a little harder."
How's about it? Wouldn't that be much more entertaining? Anybody with me?
Peace and Happy Friday to all you fine folks out there. Keep on Cookin'.








14 comments:
You never give us the recipes in a rough enough form! I'm still on tenterhooks, waiting to find out what the secret texturing ingredients to your faux bacon are!
If you want some criticism, then sure: I think the steak sauce adds a slightly funny off taste to your fillet mignon. I intend to try leaving it out next time, and perhaps adding some salt.
You always crack me up...thanks!
As for recipe testing, I have done some where I needed to make modifications. I just told the 'owner' of the recipe how I felt it could be different, and what I did the second time around. If I ever test a recipe for you and it sucks (which I doubt it would) , I will be sure to use your method of feedback.
LOL...im with you!
also, i do care, so hurry up and perfect your turkey-like recipe ;)
I'm guessing most testers just don't blog about the recipes that don't work out.
yeah in testing we usually don't say it was horrible (cause it usually isn't that bad, a good cook would know that before they handed it down) but it often comes out like "I wasn't a big fan of this. Too salty, directions were wierd, etc"
But I think yours is more directly honest. No mistaking what you meant.
I'm not inclined to buy a future cookbook based merely on a preview or two by testers. I'm more likely to buy it based on reviews by a bunch of folks after it's been published. Sometimes I find the "Oh, look what's going to be in so-and-so's future cookbook!" posts off-putting. Yeah. I'm weird. The majority opinion isn't always more valuable when considering recipes. Individual tastes vary. Needs vary. Ingredient availability varies. I tried a popular mac-n-cheese recipe from the June issue of Vegetarian Times. It was a winning recipe from a reader poll and a dish served in an Oregon restaurant. Lots o' folks must love it. Me? One word. Ick. Then there was that bbq eggplant "steak" recipe I found somewhere. My poor husband...he still shudders over that. Hey. Did you know some people actually like beets?
By the by, you're one of my favorite bloggers. You've got personality. I'm gonna buy me one of those someday...
That soy-free turkey-like recipe sounds like something I HAVE to make! I hope you get that recipe perfected soon...I will give you honest feedback on what I think when you do!
I have been a recipe tester before, and I have given some less than favorable reviews before--although nothing like what you wrote! That WOULD be much more entertaining, though!
Courtney
Yay for soy free stuff! (You can keep those recipes coming *grin*).
As for testing recipes, I've only tested for one person and I was honest when things didn't work or I didn't like it. I usually figure if it sucked for me I either did something wrong or it just wasn't something I liked the taste of.
(If I ever make something of yours that stinks though I'll be sure to email you my complaints :P)
I want you to work you buns off this weekend and perfect your turkey recipe ok! I promise I will tell you if it sucks. :o) One last note, since I have made many of your recipes and have yet to have one suck, this one probably wont.
don't worry...testers give me "constructive" criticism on my recipes all of the time. i swear.
those muffin turkeys are GENIUS! almost as genius as cedar bonz!
Yes - there are those of us that care about your turkey recipe!
Thanks for your honest kick-ASS blog that goes where most others wouldn't....
I think they must just hold off on the bad feedback on their blogs and only post the good stuff. Then they hopefully give the feedback to the author.
Is it a rule that testers have to follow the recipe by the book? I guess it would be.
I've made a couple of your recipes and I made changes! Usually it's just adding or subtracting a spice, subbing something I didn't feel like buying or couldn't find, etc. I made your sausage stew thing the other day again and totally left out the sausage this time. I like it better without it, and so does my omni boyfriend! I think I got it from your newspaper blog. I think I upped the carrots and instead of tomato juice I used veg broth and squirts of tomato paste. David probably added soy at the end because nothing's ever salty enough for him, and I always add way more salt than you (and other recipes) call for (tasting first of course).
I don't blog a lot of the food I make because I feel like I'm ripping off the owner of the recipe. I suppose I could just LINK BACK like a normal person...
Still haven't made your filets but I totally plan to do it someday!
Oh please, perfect the curry noodle recipe. I would kill for something like that.
Post a Comment